Showing posts with label Organization Development. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Organization Development. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

After Chris Argyris we Ask, What Learning Loop are we in?

When Fred Nickols shared the news of Chris Argyris passing away, it was a rather litmus test of sorts on the ODNet list. Firstly, it was a relay from Prof Elena Antonacopoulou, of GNOSIS, University of Liverpool Management School. Secondly, there were very few who surmised his contributions to Organisation Development, as compared to when some greats in Organisation Development passed away earlier this year. 

Elsewhere outside of the ODNet, there was a fitting tribute from a Harvard Professor of Information Technology who began with this quote ““When a sage dies all are his kin and should mourn the passing.” – The Talmud". 

Prof. Andrew Macafee  says little about him, and yet; the little he shares stuns with its accuracy and impact. “I wish his work got the attention it deserves. Part of the reason why not, I believe, is that he was not only clear about organizational failure modes, but also about how much time and effort were needed to get past them. He didn’t offer quick fixes or ‘the 4-hour organization.’ Instead, he stressed that it was a real slog to make things legitimately better. I think his honesty cost him some attention, probably even a lot of it, but that’s a tradeoff I’m sure he was happy with. Chris was the most intellectually honest scholar I’ve met; watering down his medicine to make it go down easier would have been anathema to him.”

It was in the early 1990s that I began reading Overcoming Organisational Defenses. I was an ‘internal’ then eking a living out of holding up a promise for the brave new world of Human Resources Development in a family managed firm.  Fortunately for me, the young scion there took a fancy for the very literature Argyris penned from research. As business leader, he began to see the minefields and bypasses in our firm with. I was in awe of the thinking and the lucidity in Argyris’ reasoning. It drew parallel with the raw freshness of Igor Ansoff’s work on Corporate Strategy of the 1960s. Heady were the days of investing in this line of work.  We went through the pain of learning that classical Organisation Development is without frills and fancy and a lot of hard work on cognitive patterns and emotional re-framing.

Later in my own academic work regarding the evaluation of Organisation Development, I began to see the utility of theory in action, especially insofaras the life of an interventionist is concerned. The era of ‘whole systems thinking’ was picking up currency in interventions too. Today, when there is tension in the field out there to examine effectiveness of organisations beyond its own boundaries, it is but natural to enquire if the theory-in-use at one’s own firm would be similar or different to those firms outside it. When I got to meet Chris at San Francisco in 2006, he was just done with a superlative demonstration of how Appreciate Inquiry as a construct was lacking in procedural elements of theorisation. Alone, he took on a room of nearly 100 practitioners and consultants in Organisation Development on the aspect of theorisation, and none could meet his reasoning prowess, despite them wanting to.

This is probably the closest reason I can think of as to why the late Ranjan Acharya decided to have me on his team. He was the essential learner, who wished to bring to his situation the most effective that learning could offer. I remember him peering through the expositions I made to explain my work, like a child letting the ocean of organisational learning wash over the infinite sponge that he was. All I can say is that today, 27th November, Ranjan’s birth anniversary in 2013, the poignancy of Prof. Macafee’s quote from the Talmud, could not ring more truer.



In closing, I must mention that I had attempted a live application of Argyris theory in the week gone by. I held out the following Argyris tenets through a series of reflective questions I requested professors to engage each other with in the room.  ‘There seems to be a universal human tendency to design one’s actions consistently according to four basic values:
1. To remain in unilateral control;
2. To maximize winning and minimize losing;
3. To suppress negative feelings; and
4. To be as rational as possible – by which people mean defining clear objectives and evaluating their behavior in terms of whether or not they have achieved them.’

Principals and Professors alike huddled in private with me in the lunch break to say that their understanding of organisational learning shifted most with my session. Needless to say, I was proving to myself, that Argyris was not only original, but pure of thought and honest in action. I think the mention of what I state hereafter really got under the skin of educationists who wished to know the relevance of Learning Organisations. 

I asked "And would you know how he got to doing what he is now famous for in organisational learning? Well, he reflected deeply on his former secretary’s statement when he returned to collect his personal belongings from the military establishment that he served. She told him in a pleasant tone and cheerful voice, which Chris had never seen or heard before in work-life, that while in office, he was seen as like a terror and difficult to speak with from that standpoint. So, driving back home, he thought why was so much human behavior so self-frustrating, particularly in organizations? In particular, his devotion was to the question, what is it that prevents people from stating their truths in their organisation(s)?"

Seldom do such souls as Argyris walk this planet, unfettered, pristine and uncompromising in inquiry. Some learning can be unpleasant too, is it not? 

Thursday, January 26, 2012

Is OD a Part of HRD or HRD a Part of OD


Is OD a Part of HRD or HRD a Part of OD: a view
T. V. Rao
I thought this controversy is no more.

Several years ago I was invited by Dr. B. L. Maheshwari the Founder of the Centre for Organization Development to consider joining it as its Director. 

That was the time I was doing three main jobs: Chairman of the Post Graduate Program at IIMA, President of ISABS and also was in the thick of setting up the National HRD Network. ISABS facilitated the work of HRD Network by agreeing to offer a HRD Facilitators lab jointly with NHRDN. NHRDN was not known in those days and it is the magnanimity of ISABS that has facilitated NHRDN to launch its HRD Facilitators program. That was also the time the Indore Management Association launched the Indore chapter of NHRDN as a part of Indore Management Association. When I approached some people in Indore to start a Chapter of NHRDN they said, “We have a strong Management body here and why is there a need for starting another body? We will do it as a part of IMA”. I have readily agreed. That was the time HRD Network was launched in south by the Madras Management Association thanks to Dr K. M. Thiagarajan. Russi Modi inaugurated it and the NHRDN at Ahmedabad for which K. K. Verma and Anil Khandelwal were active leaders launched the ISTD, Ahmedabad chapter on NHRDN platform. There was a lot of collaboration among these bodies at that time at local chapter levels. Te questions were not asked. In fact a full issue of HRD Newsletter was devoted to HRD and OD. IIMA called its program HROD program when it offered the same for HR Facilitators and NHRDN called it HRD.

In my innocence or eagerness to promote HRD, I suggested to Dr. Maheshwari that if I have to join COD and lead it as its Director, my vision will be to make it a HRD lead institute and I would use it as a centre for HRD and Applied BS. He said I may do anything I like except changing the name of COD to CHRD or Centre for Applied Behavioural Science.  Thank God that I never asked Dr. Maheshwari to change the name of COD for me to join it!  Sometimes I wonder why Dr. Maheshwari called it Centre for Organization Development. Dr.B.L.Maheshwari set up the Centre for Organization Development (COD) in 1980 with three core values: strong client orientation, high standards of quality and an Informal Growth & performance oriented work culture. In fact Dr Maheshwari was neither a member of ISABs nor trained at NTL to the best of my knowledge. However he has done a lot to promote OD in his own way through his centre. The COD library is filled with the photographs of a number of OD stalwarts. He used largely Management by Objectives as an OD tool in his early years and latter he and the COD have done a lot of work on Organizational Culture, Performance Management, Managerial effectiveness, Coaching, Quality circles and such other areas and in a variety of sectors. The work of COD makes it clear that you need not be an accredited OD Facilitator to do solid OD work. I hold this view to HRD, Applied Behavioural Science and even Management. There have been many successful Managers who manage their firms well and they don’t have an M B A.

The answer to whether OD is a part of HRD or HRD a part of OD is in our minds and it depends on the perspective we use. I wonder sometimes why the same question is not asked with Management as a filed.  Is Management (Professional Management or all categories of Management) a part of HRD or HRD a part of Management? At National level Management is a part of HRD. The AICTE which governs Management Institutes, Engineering colleges etc. is a part of the HRD Ministry. At Institutional level HRD is a discipline and is a part of OB or HRM and OD is taught as a part of  OB or HRM. In L&T OD was conceptualised as paart of HRD and yet some years the Vice-President to whom HRD was reporting was called as Vice-President Personnel & OD. In organizations where there is no OD the question does not arise. Some organizations have separate OD cells. For example HMT several decades ago had an OD cell. In L&T no less a person then Udai Pareek recommended in as long ago as 1975 recommended OD to be part of HRD. The intention was to have HRD also undertake OD work to facilitate organizational learning. Some organizations have called their training facility as HRD Institute.  

In my view OD is not a function. It is a process, it has technology and it follows a set of values and it should remain so. I would not even want OD to become a discipline or a function. When you make anything a function in a country like India where means have a knack of becoming ends and the original purposes get quickly forgotten, I don’t recommend any one to jump and create new functions and new structures. (For example Anna Hazare movement started as movement to curb corruption a strong Lokpal is supposes to be a means to curb corruption. No on e has ever seen if Lokpal will have the real capability to curb correction. It is a pious hope of all of us. But now corruption has gone to the background and Lokpal bill has become a matter of debate and corruption continues quietly to do its work while we all debate Lokpal).
Sometimes I feel that making a discipline as a function does more harm to the discipline and its development than letting it be. The same thing happened to HRD in some organizations. There are HRD Managers not knowing whether they represent Human Resource Development or Human Resource Department. The main job of some of them is to get right agency to handle their HR through a process of outsourcing. They spend their time standardising the outsourcing practices like floating tenders to get HR services at low cost  than to offer HR services themselves. This is a clear consequence of establishing a department and giving it a mandate. I dread the ay OD becomes a department as we will have another tender floating and consulting hunting department. It was not the intention of Udai Pareek. And the first HRD Manager in the country Dr. Dennyson Pereira  has been both a member of ISABS and an NTL trained persona and has done real good OD work by taking up diagnostic studies and carrying out a number of real OD interventions in OD. He did all this as part of HRD.

 I think the issue is unnecessary. The answer to whether OD is part of HRD or HRD is part of OD depends on the need, convenience and your approach. You could be right either way and argue well your case. Both can be treated broadly as philosophies, processes, value driven disciplines, functions and departments etc. For me recognising that OD as a process and respecting it is of paramount importance and making it a function is doing disservice to the field of ever growing field of OD. It has body of knowledge and it is a wide open field. India is a proud nation. While Kurt Lewin and team developed OD is the west India had CD in the east. The Community Development programs in India started as long ago as Independent Indian started or even before had the same principles in them as OD principles: people participation, facilitation by an external facilitator trained in the respective field (agriculture, health, education etc.), with the support of the top management (village Pachayats and other influential leaders) and sued a variety of interventions.  HRD is as old as civilisation and civilisations grew as a result of people developing themselves through a variety of activities and actions including learning and development and not because of HRD Departments as they did not exist in those days!